Steve Jobs doesn’t believe in tethered music subscriptions, which have traditionally required MP3 players to include a secure clock that kills playback rights when a subscription lapses. Thus, the dominant iPod has always lacked support for such subscriptions, which has hamstrung Napster and other music subscription services.
What do you do if your product doesn’t work on the dominant hardware of the day? The answer, according to Best Buy (which scooped up Napster for $121 million last fall), is to bend the music subscription in such a way that it gets along with the iPod and iPhone — sort of.
The new Napster subscription, which launches tonight, allows users to stream any of Napster’s 7 million-plus songs to a computer for $5/month. In order to bridge the gap to the iPod, Napster will give subscribers up to five free downloads each month.
Compared to buying five songs a month from iTunes, Napster’s new offering represents a fantastic value. You pay approximately the same price for the songs, plus you get on-demand streams of everything else, for free — something Apple does not allow.
The problem is, a number of sites already offer free streams of the same music. Napster now finds itself wedged between iTunes and free, ad-supported services such as imeem and MySpace:
Apple iTunes
Best Buy Napster
imeem
<p> a
streaming</p>
ap>
aree listens per month (updated); $5/month for unlimited listening</p>
awith registration</p>
<p an
s</p> <p
gn.29</p> <p
gnongs with subscription, then $0.69-$1.29</p> <p
gn<p
aligne
ming</p> <p ali
celi
celi
cetive radio; stream 100 uploads for free; <a href="htt0</a></p> <p
gn="cer
playlists online</p> <p align="
er="
erper month for non-subscribers</p> <p align="
erration</p>
<p>For no
onsumerill likely continue to prefer iTunes for paid downloads and imeem, MySpace or another free option for sampling free songs.</p> <p>But if the a
tng market continues to founder, imeem and MySpace (both of which are reportedly struggling to offer free services) could be forced to start charging monthly fees for unlimited streaming. If that happens, the market could become level enough for Napster to approach mainstream relevance for the first time since its origin as an unlicensed P2P service.</p> <p>Napster has
md to reinvent itself more times than we can count, failing to make a dent on music fans’ collective consciousness. The success of this latest move rests on how the company approaches burgeoning smartphone platforms.</p> <p>If Napster’s
anth on-demand subscription includes a mobile app for iPhone, Android, Palm Pre and Windows Mobile, it could become quite the attractive option. That way, Napster could finally succeed in implementing a music subscription on Apple’s hardware (and elsewhere) without relying on <a href="https://wwwDRM</a>.</p> <p>Such pla
nar at this time.</p> <p>We asked Nap
Chris Gorog about the possibility of moving this subscription to the mobile space on Monday morning. He pointed to the company’s <a href="https://wwwT</a>, which involvesrging fans up to $2 for each mobile download on top of data charges — hardly the sort of offering fans are likely to flock to.</p> <p>As for an iP
that might sync up with this $5 subscription, he implied that the company is entertaining the possibility. “ Napster is constantly looking at ways to extend the Napster service to other platforms and customer touch points,” he responded, “including alternate mobile platforms.”<br> </p> <h3>See Al /
<### lass="lis e/- n the Cloud, Access It on the iPhone<br></a></li> <li><a/- hough It Wants New Label Deals</a></li> <li><a hre/- </li> <li><a hre/- rm, DRM-free Music to Save Subscriptions<br></a></li> <li><a/- r for Mobile Music Downloads</a></li> <li><a hre/- or Our Time?</a></li> <li><a hre/- l Save Hollywood, Music</a></li> </ul>
